Ligne Jaune

Otages et médiatisation

Et si la médiatisation était néfaste pour les otages journalistes ? C’est la question (à rebours des idées reçues) que posait dans Libération, un ex-otage américain, David Rohde. Rebondissant sur cette analyse, nous avons souhaité, alors que deux reporters de France 3, Hervé Ghesquière et Stéphane Taponier, sont retenus en Afghanistan depuis plus d’un an, poser des questions rarement évoquées.

(…)

Dans les prises d’otages, le pouvoir tente-t-il d’intoxiquer l’opinion, en annonçant précipitamment de bonnes nouvelles non vérifiées ? Les journalistes qui traitent de la captivité de leurs confrères sont-ils parfaitement libres de ce qu’ils écrivent ? Peuvent-ils (par exemple) aborder librement la question des rançons éventuelles ? Les ravisseurs ont-ils forcément tort de considérer a priori que les journalistes peuvent être aussi, parfois, fournir des renseignements aux autorites de leur pays d’origine ? Enfin, les otages journalistes sont-ils mieux traités médiatiquement que les humanitaires, ou les expatriés qui travaillent pour des entreprises ?

Autant de questions qui ne seront peut-être pas populaires au sein de la  corporation journalistique.

Quatre journalistes ont néanmoins accepté de s’y prêter. Bertrand Boyer, président de la Société des Journalistes de France 3, Raphaëlle Bacqué, (Le Monde), membre du comité de soutien à Ghesquière et Taponier, Georges Malbrunot (Le Figaro), lui-même retenu en otage en Irak en 2005, et Jean-François Julliard, secrétaire général de Reporters sans Frontières.

L’émission est proposée par Daniel Schneidermann, préparée par Dan Israel, et déco-réalisée par François Rose.


Journalistes otages : confraternité et lignes j@unes

Be Sociable, Share!

    , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

    RÉCLAMATIONS (105)

    > Déposer une réclamation
    • […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by guybirenbaum, Gilles BRUNO. Gilles BRUNO said: Arrêter d'écouter ALCINA? RT @guybirenbaum: Otages & médiatisation : Ligne Jaune (Malbrunot, Bacqué, Julliard, Boyer) http://bit.ly/gi6UiK […]

    • little big horn dit :

      Les journalistes de france2 ont ajouté depuis quelque temps un mot de soutien aux autres otages,ce qu’ils ne faisaient pas au début.Cela atténue le sentiment qu’il y aurait deux poids deux mesures.Mais plus globalement y a-t-il un traitement de ce genre de crise qui serait parfait et qui échapperait à toute critique?

    • lovely dit :

      Un fait divers a timidement été traité à Noël: celui du journaliste retraité du Parisien. Pourtant les circonstances de sa mort étaient dignes d’un polar sordide, comme il était journaliste ses confrères se sont limités au strict minimum. Les ingrédients étaient captivants: un père bourgeois habitant le très chic 6ème, un fils désoeuvré insatisfait du montant de son argent de poche ( 500 € / mois ! ), un crime crapuleux commandité…

      L’entre soi journalistique conduit à des dérives: l’excès de zèle pour célébrer la disparition et les jours de captifs et le silence pour cacher la fin tragique d’un journaliste. Le traitement de l’information lorsqu’il s’agit de journalistes est manipulé à outrance.

    • martingrall dit :

      Chacun sait, bon les français à priori ne sont pas, jamais, chacun, qu’il ne faut JAMAIS parler des otages !! Puisque c’est l’unique but de la prise d’otages, la médiatisation d’un groupe isolé quel qu’il soit pour quoi qu’il le fasse et quoi qu’il revendiquerait!
      Et chacun sait, bon les français à priori ne sont pas, jamais, chacun, qu’au plus la médiatisation de leur groupe isolé sera continue, au moins la chance de retrouver les otages sera proche. Et pour ensuite toujours recommencer. Et d’ailleurs, ailleurs!

      A moins, et en France tout est aujourd’hui possible, plus rien jamais ne pourra plus nous étonner, que le groupe isolé soit directement organisé par les français, afin de justifier de mesures illégales et antidémocratiques comme la Loppsi 2 et autres délits que justifie la lutte “anti terrorisme”

      mais bon……

    • martingrall dit :

      ……

    • martingrall dit :

      Heu “confraternité” cela n’existe plus que chez les franc-maçons et encore pas tous!chez quelques franc-maçons est plus vrai.
      Ben confrère il faut une mère! Et qu’elle est telle

    • Pat dit :

      Des intervenants sobres et passionnants, un animateur pertinent et tenace, des échanges de qualité : bref, le webspectateur en sort informé et avec l’envie d’aller plus loin dans sa compréhension de ce sujet si délicat.

      Merci à Raphaëlle Bacqué et Bertrand Boyer pour leur courageuse action et leur main tendue vers les familles des otages non journalistes.

      Je ne souhaite pas réduire l’émission à une phrase, elle mérite d’être écoutée de bout en bout. Mais cette phrase-là, cette phrase si juste de Raphaëlle Bacqué, me pèse beaucoup : “pour lui [Nicolas Sarkosy], la communication est action”. No comment.

    • PMB dit :

      “pour lui [Nicolas Sarkosy], la communication est action”.

      Ne peut-on écrire plutôt “pour lui [Nicolas Sarkosy], l’action est de la communication” Et rien d’autre ?

    • gill68 dit :

      (10/01/2011) Michel Germaneau serait mort faute de médicaments, et pas “exécuté” comme déclaré par #sarkozy …selon JD Merchet (qui ne s’explique pas non plus l’attitude de notre président) http://bit.ly/hCRhNQ

    • iban dit :

      à voir et à méditer dans le vrac de l’épicerie:les 36 secondes de “commandant en chef sarko”,de la com et du cynisme!mais d’actualité

    • Pat dit :

      Dans le contexte, j’interprète la phrase de Raphaëlle Bacqué notamment comme “la communication se substitue à l’action”. Par delà cette interprétation personnelle, la communication est un acte de parole – au sens psycho-linguistique du terme, pardon pour le jargon – qui est ici totalement dévastateur pour les familles qui en ont été destinataires.

      Les mots ont un sens… Les “communiquants” le savent parfaitement bien, un exemple récent : http://www.lesmotsontunsens.com/seguela-le-salaire-moyen-d-un-chinois-c-est-10-du-smic-et-ils-sont-heureux-8823

    • Trackback…

      […]here are some links to some sites that we think you should visit[…]…

    • Cheap Thailand Flights…

      […]below you’ll find the link to some sites that we think you should visit[…]…

    • Discount Kasper Suits…

      […]in the following are a handful of web page links to places which I link to for the fact we feel they are definitely worth checking out[…]…

    • cool!…

      [..]So I checked out this amazing site today.[..]…

    • Interesting Sites…

      […]while the sites we link to below are completely unrelated to ours, we think they are worth a read, so have a look[…]…

    • Travel Offers…

      […]these sites may not be fully related towards our website however we certainly believe that you must visit all of them[…]…

    • Chip in Your XBox 360…

      […]below you’ll find the link to some sites that we think you should visit[…]…

    • Paleo Diet dit :

      Internet Reviews…

      […]just below, are some totally unrelated sites to ours, however, they are definitely worth checking out[…]…

    • Official Colon Cleanse…

      […]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[…]…

    • Mens Health and Fitness…

      […]Take the time to read or visit the subject matter or sites we have linked to below[…]…

    • ICICI Money to India…

      […]listed below are a couple of hyper-links to web sites that we link to because we think they really are really worth browsing[…]…

    • Dane Burton…

      […]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[…]…

    • OpenOffice Download…

      […]here are some hyper-links to internet sites that we connect to as we think they will be well worth checking out[…]…

    • Brother xl2610…

      […]Brother XL2610 sewing machine is versatile which can support plenty of function you do[…]…

    • Fashion Style Blog…

      […]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[…]…

    • OpenOffice Download…

      […]right here are several urls to internet sites that we link to because we believe there’re worth checking out[…]…

    • Travel Offers…

      […]all of these online websites could certainly not be absolutely related to our web site however we unquestionably think you must visit them[…]…

    • ICICI Bank dit :

      ICICI Money to India…

      […]in the following are a handful of links to internet sites which we link to for the fact we think they really are worthy of checking out[…]…

    • nanoDeals | Der Marktplatz fuer kleine Deals…

      […]we like to honor other sites on the web, even if they aren’t related to us, by linking to them. Below are some sites worth checking out[…]…

    • Travel Offers…

      […]these websites may possibly certainly not be completely relevant with our web site however we most certainly believe that you should really see them[…]…

    • Child Gifts…

      […]just below, are some totally unrelated sites to ours, however, they are definitely worth checking out[…]…

    • free music downloading sites…

      […]we like to honor other sites on the web, even if they aren’t related to us, by linking to them. Below are some sites worth checking out[…]…

    • Get Money With Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]what follows are a couple of references to internet pages I always link to since we think they’re definitely worth browsing[…]…

    • OpenOffice Download…

      […]what follows are a few hyper-links to websites which we connect to because we think there’re seriously worth browsing[…]…

    • Get Money With Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]here are a couple of urls to websites that we connect to for the fact we believe they are worthy of browsing[…]…

    • Get Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]following are a couple of url links to web-sites which I connect to seeing as we think they really are truly worth checking out[…]…

    • Fat burner…

      […]while the sites we link to below are completely unrelated to ours, we think they are worth a read, so have a look[…]…

    • Get Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]these are a couple of web page links to online websites I always link to seeing as we feel there’re worth browsing[…]…

    • Travel Deals…

      […]number of internet sites that are posted under, via our perspective are surely worth browsing[…]…

    • Online Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]right here are a handful of hyper-links to internet websites we link to for the fact we think they will be worth checking out[…]…

    • Trackback…

      […]With So Many Crappy Sites Out There, When We Stumble Across[…]…

    • Service AC / HVAC…

      […]below you’ll find the link to some sites that we think you should visit[…]…

    • OpenOffice Download…

      […]in the following are some listings to websites online that we connect to because we think they will be definitely worth browsing[…]…

    • Money For College Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]what follows are some url links to websites which we link to as we believe there’re seriously worth browsing[…]…

    • ICICI Money to India…

      […]following are several web page links to web pages we connect to because we believe there’re seriously worth browsing[…]…

    • Meratol uk dit :

      Trackback…

      […]below you’ll find the link to some sites that we think you should visit[…]…

    • May Cobb dit :

      Andres Turner…

      […]I have searched all over the internet for the absolute best offer. so far the best i found was at […]…

    • London Escorts Agency…

      […]just below, are some totally unrelated sites to ours, however, they are definitely worth checking out[…]…

    • ICICI Money to India…

      […]what follows are several url links to internet sites we link to since we feel they really are truly worth browsing[…]…

    • Get Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]below are a few urls to sites that we connect to because we feel they really are worthwhile visiting[…]…

    • OpenOffice Download…

      […]listed here are several listings to internet sites which I link to since we believe they will be well worth browsing[…]…

    • Money for College-Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]below are a couple of urls to online sites I always connect to since we think they are worth visiting[…]…

    • OpenOffice Download…

      […]the following are a handful of web links to web sites that we link to for the fact we feel they’re definitely worth browsing[…]…

    • Online Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]following are several references to places we link to since we believe they’re worthwhile checking out[…]…

    • Get Money With Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]right here are several links to internet websites I always link to seeing as we feel they will be worth visiting[…]…

    • The Best Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]below are a few hyper-links to web pages which we connect to as we think there’re worth browsing[…]…

    • Get Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]the following are some hyper-links to sites we connect to seeing that we think they will be seriously worth browsing[…]…

    • Money for College-Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]right here are a few web page links to websites online which we link to seeing that we think they’re definitely worth checking out[…]…

    • Money for College-Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]right here are a couple of links to sites I always connect to as we feel they are definitely worth checking out[…]…

    • The Best Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]these are a couple of listings to web-sites I always link to since we think they really are well worth visiting[…]…

    • Online Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]what follows are several hyper-links to webpages which I link to seeing as we feel they really are worthy of checking out[…]…

    • ghosts pictures…

      […]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[…]…

    • free CNA training…

      […]for more information pertaining to the article, be sure to check out[…]…

    • The Best Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]right here are a couple of links to internet websites which we connect to seeing as we feel they really are seriously worth visiting[…]…

    • The Best Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]following are several links to internet pages we connect to for the fact we think there’re worth checking out[…]…

    • The Best Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]in the following are several urls to internet sites we link to as we feel they really are definitely worth visiting[…]…

    • Money For College Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]in the following are a few hyper-links to internet pages we link to for the fact we feel they’re definitely worth visiting[…]…

    • invented dit :

      Shop…

      […]In older days baby toys consists of cars, automobile and aero planes[…]…

    • Get Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]what follows are some references to webpages that we connect to since we think they really are really worth browsing[…]…

    • Top websites…

      […]our staff members always like to go to many other sites on the internet for valuable info. Have a look at the internet site following[…]…

    • Money for College-Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]here are a handful of url links to sites that we link to seeing as we think there’re well worth checking out[…]…

    • The Best Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]right here are a few url links to web sites I always connect to seeing as we believe they will be worthy of visiting[…]…

    • ICICI Bank dit :

      ICICI Money to India…

      […]the following are a couple of listings to websites which we connect to seeing as we feel they’re definitely worth checking out[…]…

    • Get Money With Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]listed here are several listings to online websites we connect to for the fact we think they’re really worth visiting[…]…

    • Web Site Builders Says It’s An Incredible Article Cool!…

      Excellent post, reckoned I would add some not related posts, nevertheless really worthwhile having a look!!!…

    • slept dit :

      loft…

      […]These history can now and again tell ‘n overall narrative of why one thing is disappointment[…]…

    • Colon Cleanse dit :

      Official Colon Cleanse…

      […]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[…]…

    • netflix dit :

      Miss America 2011…

      […]in the following are a couple of links to sites we link to since we think they really are well worth visiting[…]…

    • call center dit :

      Philippines call center…

      […]below you’ll find the link to some sites that we think you should visit[…]…

    • For Your Information…

      Im inexperienced to blogging and recently found out about trackbacks, which I guess is a means for me to acknowledge your internet site through a linkback through mine. I ran into your site in the “currently buzzing” segment of one of the bookmarking…

    • pet rats…

      […]we like to honor other sites on the web, even if they aren’t related to us, by linking to them. Below are some sites worth checking out[…]…

    • icann dit :

      Clubpenguin…

      […]listed here are several web links to internet pages we connect to seeing that we think they will be worthy of visiting[…]…

    • Philips LED light bulbs…

      […]while the sites we link to below are completely unrelated to ours, we think they are worth a read, so have a look[…]…

    • Home Appliance Service…

      […]just below, are some totally unrelated sites to ours, however, they are definitely worth checking out[…]…

    • current movie releases…

      […]just below, are some totally unrelated sites to ours, however, they are definitely worth checking out[…]…

    • Monsieur,

      Cette semaine sur notre blog (http://de-jour-en-jour.over-blog.com) un dossier est consacré aux prises d’otages et à la question de la médiatisation.

      Bien cordialement,

      Thibaut Lengaigne pour “De Jour en Jour”

    • Websites worth visiting……

      […]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[…]………

    DÉposer une RÉCLAMATION

    Souscrire à ces commentaires.

    *

    *Champs Requis