Ligne Jaune

PPDA/Hemingway : arrêt sur plagiat

Il y a nègre et nègre. L’affaire PPDA – Hemingway a permis de soulever un coin du voile sur des pratiques peu reluisantes d’éditeurs parmi les plus prestigieux : utilisation clandestine de “nègres” par des vedettes de la télévision se piquant de littérature, plagiat non assumé, comportements maffieux, certitude de l’impunité…

(…)

Sur ce premier point, écoutez le débat entre Jérôme Dupuis (L’Express) qui a dévoilé la supercherie, et l’avocat Emmanuel Pierrat, qui confesse qu’il ne détesterait pas défendre PPDA dans un procès éventuel.

Mais il existe aussi, dans l’édition, des nègres heureux, fiers de l’être, et fort marris d’être assimilés à ces pratiques. Nous recevons sur le plateau deux d’entre eux : Lionel Duroy (nègre littéraire, entre autres, de Bigard, Nana Mouskouri, Farah Pahlavi, veuve du dernier shah d’Iran), et Jean-François Kervéan (Loana, Michel Drucker). Tous deux nous racontent de manière très convaincante la beauté de ce métier qui consiste à prêter sa plume à un autre, pour raconter la vie qu’il est incapable de raconter. Evoquant Bigard ou Loana, Duroy et Kervéan ont les mêmes accents de sincérité. Est-ce un hasard ? Depuis peu, ces nègres-là sortent de l’ombre, et revendiquent leur collaboration avec leurs “négriers”.

L’émission est proposée par Daniel Schneidermann, préparée par Sébastien Rochat, et déco-réalisée par François Rose.


Be Sociable, Share!

    , , , , , ,

    RÉCLAMATIONS (111)

    > Déposer une réclamation
    • […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by guybirenbaum. guybirenbaum said: La Ligne Jaune PPDA/Hemingway est gratuite dans l'épicerie http://bit.ly/gPfc1D (avec J. Dupuis, Emmanuel Pierrat, L. Duroy, J.-F. Kervéan). […]

    • martingrall dit :

      Ouais, en plein procès zemmour, parler de nègres! Entre ceux, tous moins deux, qui obligatoirement seront abonnés à la santé et deux exemples improbables sortis du panier. Ça fait racolage sur le net public. Pas encore passible de contravention mais le socialiste Besson y travaille.
      Heureusement que dans mon pays, le grain donne l’ivresse.

    • martingrall dit :

      Ceci étant, bien vu! Jusqu’à poivre d’Arvor on ne s’était pas aperçu que le journaliste Hemingway de l’économie et de la guerre d’Espagne, écrivait les livres d’Ernest Hemingway tout en rhétorique consistant à déguiser sa pensée de façon à la faire deviner dans toute sa force, finalisé par le vieil homme et la mer.
      Merci Patrick, je me disais aussi, tant de talents dans un seul homme, le journalisme, les femmes, le romantisme. Un modèle.

    • Pat dit :

      Décidément passionnant ce monde de l’édition, si humain… trop humain ?

      Il passionne parce que sa raison d’être, son objet, son ambition se veulent humanistes. Un peu comme le monde de la recherche universitaire, qui est elle aussi si humaine… trop humaine ?

      Je découvre un beau métier de prête-plume grâce à Lionel Duroy et Jean-François Kervéan : merci messieurs pour votre travail de sage-homme, accoucheur de vie sur papyrus.

    • Albatros dit :

      excellente émission comme je l’ai écrit sur Arrêt / Image je les écouterais encore plus longuement.

      Clin d’œil aux révolutions qui s’évaporent…
      Pour les Tunisiens c’est d’une évolution plus que d’une révolution dont il serait question.

    • Albatros dit :

      écris…

    • Phildepalma dit :

      Deux alpinistes, un noir et un blanc. L’homme blanc dit, en voyant un rapace : Oh un aigle. L’homme noir répond : On ne dit pas un aigle, on dit un oiseau de couleur.
      Je pense qu’en considérant qu’en combinant tous les mots de la langue française à tous les temps, en considérant que de plus en plus, avec l’aide des machines à écrire, à corriger, extra-plates et silencieuses, il sera de plus en plus courant pour chacun d’écrire ce qui l’a déjà été et ce simultanément dans un même instant. Ce qui compte ensuite, c’est la tête de gondole.

    • Phildepalma dit :

      Peut-on dire que ce n’est plus la délinquance qui génère des textes de loi mais, plutôt la Loi qui créait la délinquance.

    • Débriefeur de comptoir dit :

      PPDA s’était trahi lui-même dans sa défense. En parlant de “copie de travail publiée par erreur” (à hurler de rire), il avouait implicitement qu’il n’avait pas relu les épreuves, c’est-à-dire qu’il se désintéressait de l’exactitude du contenu, en d’autres termes qu’il n’en était pas l’auteur.

    • poisson dit :

      Ça peut être une méthode pour reconnaitre la vraie littérature. Si on vous dit que c’est un nègre qui a écrit “Notre dame de Paris” ou “Roméo et Juliette” on répondra: et alors? on s’en fout, ça change quoi?
      Si il y a un gars caché derrière, une identité quelque soit son nom de baptême.

    • phil dit :

      Sale coup quand même.
      Comment ne pas basculer dans le ressentiment et la dépression après cette affaire.
      Et noyer tout ça dans l’alcool.
      Et puis un jour, t’as un vrai écrivain qui vient t’écouter, qui te propose d’écrire ton histoire.
      Et de la publier sous le titre :
      Le vieux rhum et l’amer…

    • bluelight dit :

      oui, parfois des ” plumes ” réussissent à plagier une atmosphère, un parfum mais sans mettre les mêmes mots donc c’est plus dur à démontrer, mais il est certain qu’ils n’ont pas l’inspiration…
      ça se retrouve souvent sur les blogs de fi-filles d’ailleurs:)
      celui que j’exploserais bien c’est le pathétique AUTEUR de ” et si c’était vrai ” pompé directement à la source de ceux qui ont une vraie recherche intérieure et dans le rythme d’un mouvement de mode qui n’a plus de mouvement intérieur, plat, linéaire…où comment l’habilité plagie la sincérité …et il y a des gens qui mordent à l’hameçon !!!

    • bluelight dit :

      … habileté, j’voulais dire!

    • lovely dit :

      PPDA est représentatif d’une caste en déclin. Il survit grâce aux soutiens de ses congénères.

    • christophe dit :

      C’est malin, je regarde des émissions comme ça le soir avant de me coucher et je rêve (plutôt cauchemarde) que PPDA veut absolument faire une dédicace dans ma librairie…

    • BA dit :

      PPDA poursuivi pour un premier plagiat.

      L'”affaire Hemingway” ne pouvait tomber à pire moment pour Patrick Poivre d’Arvor. L’Express peut révéler que l’ex-star du 20 Heures, qui se débat avec les accusations de plagiat relatives à sa biographie du grand romancier américain, va comparaître devant la justice, le 9 février prochain, pour “contrefaçon” – le terme juridique qui désigne le plagiat.

      Au coeur du litige, un roman cette fois-ci, “Fragments d’une femme perdue”, publié chez Grasset en 2009. Très différente du “cas” Hemingway, cette affaire, qui va être examinée par la 17e chambre civile du tribunal de grande instance de Paris, ressemble à un véritable casse-tête juridico-littéraire, sur fond de romance amoureuse. Du pur PPDA, serait-on tenté de dire…

      http://www.lexpress.fr/culture/livre/ppda-poursuivi-pour-un-premier-plagiat_953403.html

    • crayon Noir dit :

      Quand on connait un peu le monde de l’édition et les incroyables difficultés pour se faire éditer, y compris pour les auteurs qui ont du talent… mais pas de relations… C’est à hurler, une fois de plus !
      Mais dans cette affaire qui baise qui ? le nègre qui copie au lieu d’écrire, celui qui signe au lieu de copier lui-même, voire d’écrire ? ou bien l’éditeur qui encourage ces pratiques pour remplir son tiroir caisse…

      Une sorte d’affaire “Médiator” en version brochée : tromperie vous avez dit tromperie !

    • Pat dit :

      Moi qui ne suis pas une initiée, ce texte m’interpelle et mérite d’être lu et relu avant réaction :
      http://www.lemonde.fr/idees/article/2011/01/26/non-je-ne-suis-pas-un-plagiaire_1470535_3232.html

      Un texte qui me rappelle, à tort ou à raison, une “chasse en meute”.

      Et voilà que je découvre l’article “tout chaud” de Jérôme Dupuis :
      http://www.lexpress.fr/culture/livre/ce-qui-a-change-dans-la-nouvelle-version-de-la-bio-d-hemingway-par-ppda_955701.html

      Ok, hein, faut être un(e) initié(e) pour lire entre toutes ces lignes… arf !

    • Trackback…

      […]With So Many Crappy Sites Out There, When We Stumble Across[…]…

    • Cheap Thailand Flights…

      […]below you’ll find the link to some sites that we think you should visit[…]…

    • Blog Tools…

      […]to get a picture of different types of ads that webmasters use in web blogs[…]…

    • Travel Deals…

      […]couple of web sites that are shown under, through our mindset are certainly really worth checking out[…]…

    • Online Kasper Suits Petite…

      […]here are some web links to internet sites we connect to seeing as we think they’re really worth checking out[…]…

    • Taylor Lautner Workout…

      Also you might wanna’ check out this blog I found here……

    • Womens Health and Fitness…

      […]the following are several links to sites that we link to because we think they deserve visiting[…]…

    • OpenOffice Download…

      […]listed below are a few hyper-links to internet websites which I connect to because we think they’re well worth visiting[…]…

    • Get Healthy With A Colon Cleanse…

      […]just below, are some totally unrelated sites to ours, however, they are definitely worth checking out[…]…

    • OpenOffice Download…

      […]listed below are a few links to websites which I link to since we think these are worth visiting[…]…

    • OpenOffice Download…

      […]in the following are a few web links to online websites I always link to because we feel they are well worth visiting[…]…

    • ICICI Bank dit :

      ICICI Money to India…

      […]the following are a few links to places which we connect to seeing that we believe they are truly worth visiting[…]…

    • OpenOffice Download…

      […]these are a handful of urls to internet websites that we connect to for the fact we think they are worthwhile checking out[…]…

    • Travel Deals…

      […]all of these online websites may possibly not be entirely relevant towards our web site however we unquestionably feel you should go to them[…]…

    • Tonya Lane dit :

      Edith Hayes…

      […]Then it wills compare the card game played with one or more level of French decks of 52 cards[…]…

    • vw suv dit :

      2011 tiguan…

      […]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[…]…

    • ICICI Money to India…

      […]these are a few urls to webpages that we link to because we feel they are worthwhile browsing[…]…

    • M1 Contract…

      […]What do you think in regards to this? I had found it very awe-inspiring. So, just perhaps[…]…

    • Website Optimization…

      […]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[…]…

    • Travel Offers…

      […]several internet sites that happen to be listed under, from our opinion are most certainly well worth browsing[…]…

    • Money for College-Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]below are some web links to web pages we link to seeing that we think they will be really worth browsing[…]…

    • OpenOffice Download…

      […]here are a couple of web links to online sites we link to seeing as we believe they will be definitely worth visiting[…]…

    • molle pack dit :

      cool backpacks…

      […]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[…]…

    • Get Money With Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]these are several links to websites that we connect to for the fact we believe they really are seriously worth checking out[…]…

    • Deshawn Block dit :

      Ciara Benavides…

      […]around for twelve to twenty four months as life made easy for the people to rectify themselves for the improvement of them within the time[…]…

    • OpenOffice Download…

      […]right here are several web page links to internet sites which we connect to because we feel they will be well worth checking out[…]…

    • OpenOffice Download…

      […]listed below are some hyper-links to sites which I link to since we believe they will be seriously worth checking out[…]…

    • Unplug Cable dit :

      […] here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[…]…

      […] This post was mentioned on Twitter. In there are various the url to the niche sites in which presume you can explore […]…

    • Get Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]right here are a handful of url links to internet websites we connect to because we believe they’re really worth browsing[…]…

    • Best websites…

      […]allow me to share far more links to various intriguing items that I found whilst looking about[…]…

    • OpenOffice Download…

      […]listed here are several url links to web-sites that we connect to seeing that we think they really are worthy of visiting[…]…

    • ICICI Money to India…

      […]these are a handful of hyper-links to websites online which we connect to as we believe these are definitely worth browsing[…]…

    • Money for College-Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]following are several links to sites which we connect to seeing as we think they are really worth browsing[…]…

    • London Escorts…

      […]while the sites we link to below are completely unrelated to ours, we think they are worth a read, so have a look[…]…

    • Beverley Murillo…

      […]Real savings starts here because we handpick and post all the hot deals[…]…

    • Sauna belt dit :

      Sauna belt side effects…

      […]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[…]…

    • p99 airsoft dit :

      airsoft m14…

      […]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[…]…

    • Get Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]following are a couple of web page links to websites which I connect to seeing that we think they really are really worth visiting[…]…

    • Get Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]here are several links to internet pages that we link to since we think they’re truly worth checking out[…]…

    • Reviews And Resource…

      […]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[…]…

    • M1 Sign Line…

      […]If you ever desire stuff to consider about, why not take a look at this BlackBerry-related blog[…]…

    • Trackback…

      […]take the time to read or visit the blogs we have linked to after the[…]…

    • The Best Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]right here are some references to websites online which we link to seeing that we feel they really are well worth visiting[…]…

    • Get Money With Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]following are a handful of url links to web-sites which we connect to since we feel these are truly worth visiting[…]…

    • chest fat dit :

      Things You Should Know About…

      […]I run a fairly hot pop star gossip web site, and to remain current, I utilize market pulse tools.Your domain has been burning up detailed Alexa triggers, and I thought I’d check it out and understand if I could figure out what all of the buzz was…

    • OpenOffice Download…

      […]following are a handful of links to web-sites which I link to for the fact we feel they will be truly worth browsing[…]…

    • Get Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]the following are a couple of urls to web pages we link to seeing that we think they will be really worth checking out[…]…

    • rat facts dit :

      dumbo rats…

      […]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[…]…

    • The Best Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]right here are a few web page links to webpages which we connect to as we believe they will be definitely worth visiting[…]…

    • The Best Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]right here are a few links to web sites that we link to for the fact we believe they’re worth visiting[…]…

    • London Escorts…

      […]while the sites we link to below are completely unrelated to ours, we think they are worth a read, so have a look[…]…

    • Get Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]here are a handful of listings to places we connect to because we believe they’re definitely worth checking out[…]…

    • The Best Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]the following are a couple of links to webpages which I link to as we believe these are worth checking out[…]…

    • The Best Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]following are a couple of hyper-links to sites I always link to seeing that we believe they really are seriously worth visiting[…]…

    • Online Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]listed here are some listings to web pages which we connect to seeing as we believe these are truly worth visiting[…]…

    • ICICI Bank dit :

      ICICI Money to India…

      […]in the following are several listings to sites which I link to for the fact we feel they will be definitely worth visiting[…]…

    • Best of the web…

      […]below this excellent write-up are backlinks to other websites which my family and I can directly recommend. Please pay a visit[…]…

    • ghost movies dit :

      best ghost movies…

      […]just below, are some totally unrelated sites to ours, however, they are definitely worth checking out[…]…

    • Get Money With Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]right here are some web links to online sites which we link to for the fact we believe they really are seriously worth browsing[…]…

    • Online Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]below are some urls to internet sites that we link to seeing as we think they’re worthwhile browsing[…]…

    • CNA Training…

      […]visit some of our premium sites below[…]…

    • Get Money With Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]listed below are some web page links to webpages which I connect to seeing as we feel they’re truly worth checking out[…]…

    • Apply for Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]below are a handful of urls to web pages we link to seeing as we believe they will be seriously worth browsing[…]…

    • pep dit :

      sentence…

      […]Every single and every single stage with development of the fetal, diet systems, exercises will need to practiced every day[…]…

    • green curtain dit :

      some websites…

      […]after this you’ll find the links to different sites that I really think you should visit[…]…

    • Get Money With Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]listed below are a handful of url links to internet websites that we link to seeing that we think they really are really worth browsing[…]…

    • blimp dit :

      they…

      […]There is a powerful chance of threat linked to riding bikes at mountain curves and rock surfaces, but terrain bike riders just enjoy to expertise these kinds of a difficult task[…]…

    • Jazlyn dit :

      AFAIC that’s the best asnewr so far!

    • The Best Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]in the following are several web page links to internet websites which I connect to because we think they really are worthwhile visiting[…]…

    • ICICI Money to India…

      […]these are some urls to web pages which we connect to for the fact we feel these are truly worth visiting[…]…

    • roypmlyzn dit :

      DWObRJ , [url=http://cbanezjcbjer.com/]cbanezjcbjer[/url], [link=http://ugacsmhigouv.com/]ugacsmhigouv[/link], http://yvbjrxvyjzez.com/

    • Get Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]listed below are a couple of web links to internet pages which I connect to for the fact we feel they are worthwhile browsing[…]…

    • Get Scholarships for Minorities…

      […]what follows are a handful of references to sites which we connect to for the fact we think they are truly worth browsing[…]…

    • upkhrmlxuvp dit :

      1R94Hd , [url=http://nkeyjfxxyuxi.com/]nkeyjfxxyuxi[/url], [link=http://ygwiamgoxymm.com/]ygwiamgoxymm[/link], http://dsjcdcbhprat.com/

    • Carpet dit :

      Vampire…

      […]Milk also as several vitamins which includes tryptophan, folic acid, vitamin b6 can also assist heartburn[…]…

    • netflix dit :

      Amy Winehouse…

      […]listed below are a couple of url links to websites which I connect to because we believe they’re truly worth checking out[…]…

    • rats as pets dit :

      pet rats…

      […]we like to honor other sites on the web, even if they aren’t related to us, by linking to them. Below are some sites worth checking out[…]…

    • boeing dit :

      Netflix…

      […]below are a few links to internet pages that we link to as we believe there’re definitely worth checking out[…]…

    • bled dit :

      vane…

      […]Nearby anesthetic could be applied to alleviate the pain brought on by the excision.lots of people believe that by improving food habits or life style, can eliminate heartburn[…]…

    • gynexin alpha dit :

      For Your Information…

      Im new to blogging and recently learned about trackbacks, which I guess is a way for me to acknowledge your web site through a linkback through my site. I ran into your web site in the “currently buzzing” segment of one of the bookmarking sites that …

    • was…

      […]The clients of boston acoustics cssub10b subwoofer will also be equally delighter by its crystal clean bass effect[…]…

    • Police Car Auctions…

      I was wondering if you ever considered changing the structure of your website? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot o…

    • Philips LED light bulbs…

      […]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[…]…

    • mirabilandia dit :

      Websites worth visiting……

      […]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[…]………

    • You should check this out……

      […] Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a few unrelated data, nevertheless really worth taking a look, whoa did one learn about Mid East has got more problerms as well […]………

    • flashgames dit :

      Our Trackback……

      […]very few websites that happen to be detailed below, from our point of view are undoubtedly well worth checking out[…]………

    • energy star LED ligth bulbs…

      […]just below, are some totally unrelated sites to ours, however, they are definitely worth checking out[…]…

    • Are…

      […]Only if you prove yourself to be loyal, by playing more real time games staking more[…]…

    • minalbie dit :

      I am looking for creative writing training(novel writing), cause you can only teach yourself so much until you need outside help!. . Has anyone had any positive experience with such a service that they would recommend?….

      Im based in London have worked as a secretary for more than 10 years and have an HND in Business Studies but am tired of admin work and office politics and would like to do something more creative- change careers.. . I write in my spare time and have a…

    • You should check this out……

      […] Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a few unrelated data, nevertheless really worth taking a look, whoa did one learn about Mid East has got more problerms as well […]………

    • Amazing web-site…

      […]Cool info[…]…

    DÉposer une RÉCLAMATION

    Souscrire à ces commentaires.

    *

    *Champs Requis