France Soir, un journal qui ne sert à rien ?

Nous avions dû annuler une « Ligne Jaune » consacrée à France Soir. Nous avons absolument voulu réussir à la faire. Et, comme le montre l’émission tournée cette semaine, nous avons probablement eu tort. Parce que tenter de comprendre « l’opération France-Soir » ne mène nulle part…

Nous avions dû annuler une « Ligne Jaune » consacrée à France Soir. Nous avons absolument voulu réussir à la faire. Et, comme le montre l’émission tournée cette semaine, nous avons probablement eu tort. Parce que tenter de comprendre « l’opération France-Soir » ne mène nulle part…

(…)

Nous voulions comprendre dans quelles conditions, avec quelle bénédiction éventuelle du pouvoir, l’oligarque russe Alexandre Pugachev avait pris le contrôle du prestigieux titre de la presse populaire française. Dans ce but, nous avons sollicité deux anciens directeurs de la rédaction, Serge Faubert et Gilles Bornais. Ils sont accompagnés sur le plateau de Simon Piel, du site Bakchich, et de Sebastien Rochat, auteur sur @si d’une enquête sur France-Soir.

L’émission ne parvient absolument pas à percer le mystère du rôle présumé (fantasmé ?) de l’Elysée.

S’en dégage, néanmoins, un savoureux portrait du jeune oligarque russe, qui rêve de faire un journal « people » à scandale.

Apparaissent aussi sur notre plateau les limites de l’opération : quelle influence, à l’heure d’Internet, peut prétendre exercer ce journal qui, malgré les millions déversés, ne se donne manifestement pas les moyens de ses ambitions ?

Enfin, en tant qu’animateur (je déteste ce mot…) le manque d’intérêt de cette émission montre, pour moi, de manière éclairante qu’un dispositif non contradictoire et simplement à visée « analytique » n’est pas forcément opérant.  L’absence des membres de l’actuelle hiérarchie du quotidien nous handicape.

Plus que jamais, je reste persuadé que sans contradiction, sans opposition, sans débat, on apporte moins.

Pour ne pas dire rien. Comme France Soir ?

L’émission est proposée par Daniel Schneidermann et réalisée par François Rose.


Pugachev, l’oligarque qui adore Sophia Loren
envoyé par lignejaune. – L’actualité du moment en vidéo.

14 Commentaires

  1. PPPB captcha yo!

  2. yo !

  3. Superbe Completely Automated Public Turing test to Tell Computers and Humans Apart ! 🙂

  4. Question subsidiaire : on en est où de l’imbroglio juridique concernant le patrimoine immobilier de France Soir ?

    N’est-ce pas ce (possible) gros magot qui attire autant de monde depuis si longtemps vers ce journal moribond – voire inutile ?

    Question rarement posée.

    Arf !

    Zgur

  5. Ah, je me disais aussi en écoutant cette émission (je ne suis pas allée jusqu’au bout) qu’elle n’apportait vraiment pas grand chose sur le sujet. Et je trouve sympa et honnête de votre part de le reconnaître et d’en analyser les raisons. Merci toutefois d’avoir essayé de percer les mystères de cette abracadabrantesque relance.

  6. Finalement c’est un peu comme l’histoire de la maîtresse de maison qui dit à ses invités: « Je suis vraiment désolé, j’ai complètement raté ma recette », et tous le monde répond : « Mais non, ne t’en fais pas, c’était très bon ». Finalement, avec peu d’infos sur ce Gugusse, on arrive à avoir un truc plutôt intéressant.
    On a quand même un sentiment de malaise avec cette affaire de France Soir. On Pense à l’époque où le Tsar Nicolas II corrompait la presse de l’époque pour vendre les emprunts russes.

  7. Je vous trouve bien dur avec vous-même. Certes, un membre important de la rédaction actuelle aurait été bienvenu. Pour le reste, vous nous avez offert un intéressant portrait de Pugachev Jr. La force d’une émission de débat/discussion comme ligne jaune est aussi sa régularité. Il faut assumer le fait qu’on ne peut pas réunir le plateau parfait chaque semaine… et faire avec ce qu’on a. Un peu comme à l’épicerie !

  8. La campagne publicitaire était très mauvaise, elle ciblait un large public sans apporter de réponses sur les orientations du journal et son plus par rapport à la concurrence.

  9. Certes pas de scoop, pas de débat contradictoire et on ne comprend toujours pas, comme vous le dites en fin d’émission, pourquoi Pugachev Jr a acheté France Soir. J’ai quand même trouvé intéressant les témoignages des anciens Directeurs de France soir. L’émission n’était pas sans intérêt, en tout cas pour moi, j’y ai appris comment le rachat de France soir s’est effectué et quelles sont les personnes vraiment à sa tête, notamment cette mystérieuse et intrigante Christiane Vulvert.Je vais aussi regarder d’un peu plus près les futurs gros titres de ce « journal » 😉

  10. Bah, j’avais vu l’emission dès mardi soir sur le site d’Asi (que je paye… à tarif smicard) et j’avais au contraire trouvé cette émission très interessante. Y avait pas de débat contradictoire, mais c’était quand même un sujet qui avait été peu traité dans la presse, « le pourquoi du comment du rachat de France Soir. »

    Donc, vous êtes trop critique par rapport à vous même Guy.

  11. I’m out of league here. Too much brain power on dsipaly!

  12. OGVFsW , [url=http://cwcwxzlnrfag.com/]cwcwxzlnrfag[/url], [link=http://qjrxpuepuikp.com/]qjrxpuepuikp[/link], http://xtprzpedvimh.com/

  13. 5xpUpt , [url=http://cpkybypkoiqq.com/]cpkybypkoiqq[/url], [link=http://gelzbmizmdzz.com/]gelzbmizmdzz[/link], http://twimryimxmcv.com/

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Cat Suits For Women - Cheapest Kasper Suits... [...]these are a handful of web links to websites online which we link to because we believe…
  2. Treasure Hunters Roadshow - awesome!... [..]this page kicked butt..[..]...
  3. corner computer desk - Top Sites... [...]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[...]...
  4. Travel Deals - Travel Offers... [...]all these sites may possibly not be totally relevant towards our site however we surely believe you should…
  5. Super Colon Cleanse - Colon Cleanse Health... [...]we like to honor other sites on the web, even if they aren't related to us, by…
  6. Taylor Lautner Workout - Taylor Lautner Workout... Also you might wanna' check out this blog I found here......
  7. proactol plus discount - Trackback... [...]we find pleasure in linking to other places on the interwebz, even though those places don’t happen to be…
  8. ICICI Bank - ICICI Money to India... [...]what follows are a few url links to websites online I always link to for the…
  9. Meratol slimming pills - Trackback... [...]we like to honor other sites on the web, even if they aren’t related to us, by linking to…
  10. Ok Dugan - Dalton Oliver... [...]just below, are some totally unrelated sites to ours, however, they are definitely worth checking out[...]...
  11. Krafty Kats Curiosity Shop Features Laurel Burch Cat Scarves, Earrings, and Prints | Fashion Style Blog - Fashion Style Blog... [...]below you'll find the link to some sites that we think you should visit[...]...
  12. OpenOffice Download - OpenOffice Download... [...]what follows are a handful of references to online websites that we connect to as we think they…
  13. Great Wolf Lodge Coupons - Travel Offers... [...]The subsequent web-sites are really various web-sites that fascinated our administrator, thus please explore all of them[...]...
  14. ICICI Money to India - ICICI Money to India... [...]what follows are several links to sites we connect to as we think they are worth…
  15. OpenOffice Download - OpenOffice Download... [...]what follows are several web page links to internet pages which we connect to for the fact we…
  16. tiguan review - safest suv... [...]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[...]...
  17. OpenOffice Download - OpenOffice Download... [...]in the following are a handful of web page links to web pages I always link to since…
  18. music downloading sites - music sharing websites... [...]while the sites we link to below are completely unrelated to ours, we think they are worth…
  19. gerber baby food - Guitar Reviews... [...]below you'll find the link to some sites that we think you should visit[...]...
  20. molle pack - backpacks for travelling... [...]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[...]...
  21. Scholarships for High School Juniors - Money for College-Scholarships for Minorities... [...]below are a few web links to web sites which we link to as we…
  22. Remit to India - ICICI Money to India... [...]what follows are a handful of web page links to sites which we connect to for…
  23. Nursing Scholarships for Minorities - The Best Scholarships for Minorities... [...]listed here are a few hyper-links to sites that we link to for the fact…
  24. Robin Fisher - Albertha Fitch... [...]us from the loss covering all the valuable articles of things bought along without our credit cards lost…
  25. Minority Women Scholarships - Money for College-Scholarships for Minorities... [...]listed below are some listings to web sites which we connect to for the fact…
  26. fat burner reviews - Berry... [...]finished reading ? don't forget that the web has many more sites[...]...
  27. Valorie Crockett - Alexis Lewis... [...]The insurance companies will provide the many of the offer to the customer were the premium must be…
  28. OpenOffice Download - OpenOffice Download... [...]listed below are several web page links to internet pages which I connect to since we think they…
  29. Taylor Lautner Workout Routine - Taylor Lautner Workout... Also you might wanna' check out this blog I found here......
  30. commuting-is-easier - [...] here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[...]... [...] This…
  31. ICICI Bank - ICICI Money to India... [...]what follows are several url links to internet sites we link to seeing as we feel…
  32. WestJet Promo Code - Travel Deals... [...]These subsequent web sites are really many sites which fascinated our administrator, therefore make sure you visit them[...]...
  33. Scholarships for Women Over 40 - Money for College-Scholarships for Minorities... [...]what follows are a handful of web links to sites we connect to seeing that…
  34. Blogging To The Bank Review - Review Site... [...]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[...]...
  35. Scholarships for African Americans - Get Money With Scholarships for Minorities... [...]listed below are some links to online websites we link to as we think…
  36. nikola tesla oscillator - nikola tesla inventions... [...]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[...]...
  37. Scholarships for African Americans - Money for College-Scholarships for Minorities... [...]following are a couple of listings to places that we link to because we feel…
  38. OpenOffice Download - OpenOffice Download... [...]what follows are some urls to online websites which I connect to because we feel there're well worth…
  39. Corner TV Stands - Favorite sites... [...]take the time to check out all of the following web sites for a lot of enlightening and…
  40. Doral Golf Resort And Spa - Great websites... [...]we always like to pay a visit to different web-sites over the internet for valuable info. Take a…
  41. Scholarships for Minorities - Get Money With Scholarships for Minorities... [...]following are a couple of listings to online sites I always link to since…
  42. OpenOffice Download - OpenOffice Download... [...]here are some url links to internet sites which I link to since we feel these are worthwhile…
  43. Scholarships for Minorities - The Best Scholarships for Minorities... [...]below are a couple of web page links to sites I always connect to as…
  44. rats are good pets - rat names... [...]below you'll find the link to some sites that we think you should visit[...]...
  45. Bill Gates Scholarship - The Best Scholarships for Minorities... [...]right here are a handful of urls to websites which we connect to since we…
  46. Nursing Scholarships for Minorities - Get Money With Scholarships for Minorities... [...]here are several links to web pages I always connect to as we believe…
  47. Scholarships for Minorities - The Best Scholarships for Minorities... [...]listed below are a handful of links to websites I always connect to as we…
  48. Nursing Scholarships for Minorities - Money for College-Scholarships for Minorities... [...]the following are a few references to websites I always link to seeing as we…
  49. Scholarships for Single Mothers - Get Money With Scholarships for Minorities... [...]listed here are a handful of links to web-sites I always link to because…
  50. College Scholarships for Women - Money for College-Scholarships for Minorities... [...]listed here are a couple of urls to online sites which we link to since…
  51. London Escorts - Escorts in London... [...]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[...]...
  52. Scholarships for Minorities - Get Scholarships for Minorities... [...]listed here are a couple of web links to web-sites that we connect to as we…
  53. trust - Luncies... [...]Also deciding to conduct the wedding on friday nights or sundays would result in a reduced reception hall rent[...]...
  54. scary pics - ghost hunters taps... [...]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[...]...
  55. Garmin Nuvi 1490LMT - Visit these great sites... [...]below are a lot more hyperlinks to a few fascinating pieces that I found while checking…
  56. Left Handed Scholarships - Online Scholarships for Minorities... [...]the following are a couple of web page links to places which I connect to for…
  57. Scholarships for High School Juniors - Get Money With Scholarships for Minorities... [...]these are a couple of hyper-links to web sites that we link to because…
  58. CNA Training Course - CNA Certification... [...]these are some fantastic sites that you should check out[...]...
  59. Scholarships for Minorities - Get Scholarships for Minorities... [...]below are several url links to online sites we connect to as we believe they really…
  60. sniper paintball guns - discount paintball... [...]below you'll find the link to some sites that we think you should visit[...]...
  61. green car - some websites... [...]just after this you'll find the links to different webpages that we think you should check out[...]...
  62. Ryan Reynolds Workout - [...]By the way you might want to check out this cool site I found...[...]... [...] In other news check this…
  63. Scholarships for Women Over 40 - Money for College-Scholarships for Minorities... [...]the following are a handful of web links to online websites which I link to…
  64. purple laptop - some websites... [...]below you will find a group of links to different webpages that I think you should check out[...]...
  65. nod - Mosquito... [...]It’s perfect to be in a position to inform the proper kind of sources from the unusual ones[...]...
  66. ICICI Money to India - ICICI Money to India... [...]in the following are several references to sites that we connect to as we feel they…
  67. Chris Hemsworth Workout - [...]By the way you might want to check out this cool site I found...[...]... [...] In other news check this…
  68. locksmith San Diego - 1.) View Point... 2.) [...]another viewpoint on this topic...
  69. swam - weld... [...]The procedure of making a custom clothing labels is very effortless and easy as it might be printed at…
  70. Chisel - skit... [...]Some compact discs are provided along these kits assists new end users to understand much more positive aspects about…
  71. grade - kin... [...]Buying statistics by location, and security of stock, additionally maneuvered by the warehouse management[...]...
  72. Colon Cleanse - Official Colon Cleanse... [...]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[...]...
  73. miss america 2011 - Clubpenguin... [...]in the following are a handful of url links to internet websites which I link to as we believe…
  74. fancy rat - pet rats... [...]we like to honor other sites on the web, even if they aren't related to us, by linking…
  75. gynexin - For Your Information... Im naive to blogs and just learned about trackbacks, which I guess is a way for me…
  76. Swung - miss... [...]There are also many exhaust system available other than this two brother exhaust system[...]...
  77. How can Thailand move out of its political and social chaos? | Full Moon Party Thailand - Full Moon Party Thailand... [...]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[...]...
  78. Philips LED light bulbs - Philips LED light bulbs... [...]below you'll find the link to some sites that we think you should visit[...]...
  79. Police Car Auctions - Police Car Auctions... Hey, I think your blog might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your website…
  80. energy star LED ligth bulbs - energy star LED ligth bulbs... [...]just below, are some totally unrelated sites to ours, however, they are definitely worth checking…
  81. recent film releases - recent release movies... [...]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[...]...

Soumettre un commentaire

Votre adresse e-mail ne sera pas publiée. Les champs obligatoires sont indiqués avec *

10 Avr, 2010

Épicerie ouverte

Prenez votre temps…

Conserves

« Y’en a un peu plus, je vous l’mets quand même ? »

Le grand remplacement

Le grand remplacement

Lorsque la vie m'éloigne de la mer, mon chien, Jedi, me promène souvent, une heure et des poussières, dans un grand domaine, celui de Saint-Cloud. Ce matin, j’avais prévu, durant notre balade rituelle, d’écouter deux interviews, en direct, tout en cheminant. F. à...

Justes

Justes

En ces temps déments où n'importe qui dit n'importe quoi, en toute impunité, juste deux visages. Ceux de Rose et Désiré Dinanceau qui cachèrent ma mère et mes grands-parents maternels, tous trois Juifs polonais, dans un débarras de six mètres carrés, du 16 juillet...